In recent years I’ve returned a bit to fiction and found
Barbara Kingsolver and Jodi Picoult to be two new (to me) favorites. My most
recent was Picoult’s My Sisters Keeper. I picked it out because I knew it was
one of the authors most popular and had also been made into a movie.
It tells the story of 13-year-old Anna, who sues her parents
for medical emancipation when she is expected to donate a kidney to her older sister
Kate, who is dying from leukemia. Actually, she was conceived and genetically programed
for this purpose and has been “donating” various fluids and bodily parts for some
time. As young teenagers are sometimes wont to do she rebels and a family
crises of the worst and most heart wrenching kind ensues. If you feel drawn to
books involving serious ethical challenges this one’s for you. And I both loved
and hated this book at the same time….It was, after a good start, way too contrived and manipulative. An unbelievably precocious teenager who hires a lawyer and cracks wise? The perfect father who take sides in a court hearing against his wifes’ judgment. She, the mother who risks all to save all. Even Judge Judy couldn’t make sense out of this soap opera. Yes, I was very conflicted about this book reading it anxiously to the very end…..