Troutbirder

Troutbirder
To Go To Troutbirders Nature Blog (click on above picture)

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Dark Hood

I was never much of a fan of cowboy stories as a young boy. Now Robin Hood, that was another matter. The neighborhood gang played it often as this picture demonstrates. That's Robin (aka Troutbirder) lower right on picture, Little John behind him, Mary Anne (aka Maid Marion) front row left, etc.


So when I picked up Outlaw, by Angus Donald, I was surprised to see a new version of my hero. This was not the happy go lucky band of sweet misfits, clad in green, who made robbing the greedy rich and giving to the needy poor their thrilling lifestyle. It the earlier 12th century version.... it was all down and dirty. Later eras, like the Victorians and Disney spiffered up Robin's image. Perhaps Donals version was really Robin as a druid, playing a Mafia boss, Godfather style . Here the violence is very graphic. R rated actually. The darkness of this tale is present in descriptions of limbs sliced, tongues diced and eyes put out with gimlets. The narrator is Alan A Dale and most of the other familiar characters show up as well.

I think it might have been the good Robin, who fought for the little people against the evil oppressors, in a highly class structured society that first set me on the path to a liberal/socialist view of the world. Where a honest democratic system preserves the golden goose of capitalism while controlling its excesses and tendencies toward monopolistic oligarchy.


Now we see Robin, in this story, as a complicated hero. Who does or orders terrible things. Not to help the poor but to use them for his goal of regaining his upper class position. Of course, this is all done by touting the notion of justice for all. Good plan. Questionable movtives.
What to make of all this? Well it's a fun story, whose interesting characters, familiar, yet different, keep moving the story along in surprising ways. I’d recommend it to anyone who wants to see a newer, shall we say more historically realistic version , of a very old tale. Which gets me to what I didn’t like about it. I like my childhood heroes to be good and heroic. Not good and bad. I’ll leave the conflicted ones to the psychiatrists .

7 comments:

Lady Bren said...

I am going to have to look for this book on audiotape!!
I have to admit I love that you chose the disney photo as that is my fave pic.
BTW thank you for being one of those who was brave enough to fight the big companies as I am one of those who had problems with what is now a black label drug. I hope my litigous remark didn't offend you. It was more intended at actions like when we sue a store for serving us hot coffee. UGGHH
Enjoying your blog!!

Montanagirl said...

I enjoyed the Kevin Costner movie version of Robin Hood.

Loree Huebner said...

I love the real oldie with Errol Flynn as Robin Hood.

Retired English Teacher said...

How fun your photo is! Do you realize that many kids today would never be allowed to play with such play things, nor would they be able to engage in the imaginative play that you did.

Thanks for the review of the book. Sounds interesting.

Arkansas Patti said...

I like my heroes pure, not conflicted also. Reality we live with, heroes we strive for. Think I'll pass. Thanks for the review.

warriormom said...

Love the picture of the gang. Thanks for the book review. I so need to get back to reading! Life gets complicated.

Catherine said...

Walt Disney Robin Hood ~ still one of my most favorite cartoons of all times. Hmmmm..... now I feel like whistling the theme song.

Of course, the cute little Fox Robin is second only to Daffy Duck Robin Hood from Bugs Bunny.... a classic! ;)

xo Catherine